Statement by Health Minister Robin Swann on Independent Neurology Inquiry Report

Date published: 21 June 2022

“My thoughts today are very much with all the patients and families affected by the neurology recall.

Panel member Professor Hugo Mascie-Taylor, Health Minister Robin Swann and Chairman Brett Lockhart QC
Panel member Professor Hugo Mascie-Taylor, Health Minister Robin Swann and Chairman Brett Lockhart QC

“Once again, on behalf of the entire health service, I extend my heartfelt apologies to all those who have been so badly let down.

“I fully appreciate that this is a harrowing day for patients and families, and that it will exacerbate the trauma already experienced.

“I want to thank the Inquiry Chair Brett Lockhart QC, Inquiry Co-Panellist Professor Hugo Mascie-Taylor, and their wider team for their vitally important work.

“The Inquiry Panel’s report is extensive and detailed. I will ensure it is given the careful and measured consideration that it deserves.  I am determined that this analysis should happen as quickly as possible.  I undertake to provide a full response to the Report’s recommendations, as soon as is practicable.

“Today’s report makes very difficult reading for anyone who cares about health and social care in Northern Ireland. It states that systems and processes in place to assure the public in respect of patient safety prior to November 2016 failed. Crucially, opportunities to intervene in relation to Michael Watt’s practice were missed over a number of years.

“The Inquiry Panel believes that without the then Belfast Trust’s Medical Director’s response in December 2016 to concerns that had been raised, and more particularly in July 2017, there is no guarantee that the problems identified in the recall would have necessarily emerged.

“It is acknowledged in the report that changes have been initiated since the neurology recall to improve patient safety.

“The entire HSC system must continue building on these improvements, guided by the Inquiry Panel’s report.

“While the reputation of our health service has undoubtedly been tarnished, we must also be mindful of the high quality, compassionate care provided every day by dedicated and skilled staff. Thankfully, they are the norm.

“Robust processes and procedures are essential to identify and deal with errant and failing practitioners. This Inquiry Report has relevance right across the HSC and indeed the entire NHS, and I will be sharing its findings with my counterparts in England, Scotland and Wales. It also raises issues about the independent health sector and the GMC.

“Health care is of immense importance and as a result there are invariably very serious consequences when it goes wrong. We must always strive to learn from such cases, and take decisive action to ensure failings do not re-occur.

“That will be the absolute priority for me and for my Department.”

Notes to editors: 

  1. The Independent Neurology Inquiry was established by the Permanent Secretary of the Department of Health in May 2018.  This was as part of a series of actions taken in response to the recall of neurology patients by the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust.  The Inquiry Panel's report can be found on the Independent Neurology Inquiry website.
  1. Health Minister Robin Swann converted the Inquiry from a non-statutory public inquiry to a statutory public Inquiry in December 2020 to ensure that the Inquiry had unfettered access to all documentation.
  2. For media enquiries please contact the DoH Press Office by email
  3. Follow us on Twitter @healthdpt
  4. The Executive Information Service operates an out of hours service For Media Enquiries Only between 1800hrs and 0800hrs Monday to Friday and at weekends and public holidays. The duty press officer can be contacted on 028 9037 8110.

Share this page

Back to top